In a significant development in the ongoing legal proceedings initiated by Khalistani separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun in the United States, a federal court in New York has formally sought assistance from Delhi's district courts to serve summons on India's National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) chief Samant Goel.
The United States District Court for the Southern District of New York has requested the Patiala House Court, Dwarka Court and Tis Hazari Court to accept the judicial documents and facilitate their delivery to the two Indian officials. The request is part of a civil lawsuit filed by Pannun, who has alleged a conspiracy to assassinate him on American soil.
The order was issued on November 13 by US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla. The court has also requested the Indian judicial authorities to provide a written record of the proceedings undertaken to effect service of the summons.
In its order, the US court stated:"This request is made pursuant to the express authorization for service of foreign judicial process under Indian law and Article 19 of the Hague Convention. The Court respectfully requests the assistance of the receiving Indian courts in effecting service of process upon the Defendants in this civil action pending before the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York."
The development comes after earlier attempts to serve the summons through the conventional diplomatic and legal channels failed to achieve the desired outcome.
Why Has the US Court Approached Delhi's District Courts?
The latest move follows a series of unsuccessful attempts by Pannun to serve legal documents on the Indian officials.
According to the court proceedings, Pannun had claimed that he attempted to serve Doval personally on three occasions during the latter's visits to the United States. However, those attempts allegedly failed after security personnel prevented him from approaching the National Security Adviser.
He also attempted to serve Doval, Goel and another individual, Vikram Yadav, through India's Central Authority at the Ministry of Law and Justice. Those efforts were also unsuccessful.
Subsequently, on November 9, the US court permitted Pannun to pursue an alternative method of serving the summons through Indian district courts under the Hague Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents.
The November 13 order formalised the request for assistance from the Delhi courts.
The US judge has directed that the summons and accompanying judicial records be transmitted to the relevant Indian courts through international mail or courier. The receiving courts have been requested to facilitate the delivery of the documents and provide a written account of the steps taken.
What Is the Gurpatwant Pannun Lawsuit About?
Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, the general counsel of the banned organisation Sikhs for Justice (SFJ), filed the civil lawsuit in 2024 before the US District Court for the Southern District of New York.
The lawsuit names the Government of India, Ajit Doval, former RAW chief Samant Goel, Vikram Yadav, Nikhil Gupta and several unidentified individuals as defendants.
Pannun has alleged that the defendants were involved in a conspiracy to assassinate him because of his activities associated with the Khalistan movement.
The lawsuit seeks to hold the named individuals and entities accountable for the alleged assassination conspiracy and seeks damages.
The allegations are part of Pannun's civil case and have not been established through a final judicial finding. The issuance or service of summons does not amount to a determination of the merits of the allegations.
India Rejects Pannun's Allegations
The Indian government has strongly rejected the lawsuit, describing the allegations against its senior officials as fabricated and malicious.
On November 10, Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal dismissed the allegations and reiterated India's position on the handling of judicial documents originating from foreign courts.
"We reject the fabricated and malicious attacks on our high officials. Also, we reject the frivolous lawsuits," Jaiswal said. He further clarified India's position on the procedure for serving legal documents, stating:
"A request for serving of judicial documents in India can only be routed through India's designated central authority, which is the Ministry of Law and Justice."
India has maintained that the allegations against its officials are baseless and has objected to the legal proceedings initiated by Pannun.
Separate From Criminal Proceedings in the US
The civil lawsuit filed by Pannun should also be distinguished from the separate criminal proceedings in the United States concerning an alleged murder-for-hire plot targeting him.
Those criminal proceedings involve Indian national Nikhil Gupta and former RAW officer Vikash Yadav. US prosecutors have alleged that Gupta was involved in coordinating an assassination attempt against Pannun, with Yadav allegedly playing a role in the conspiracy. The civil case naming Doval and Goel is a separate legal proceeding and involves allegations that have not been established by a final court judgment. The US government is not a party to Pannun's civil lawsuit.
What Happens Next?
The latest order marks another procedural step in the US court's efforts to ensure that the summons reach the two Indian officials through an alternative legal mechanism. The involvement of Delhi's district courts does not mean that the Indian officials have been found guilty or that the US court has accepted the allegations as proven. Service of summons is intended to formally communicate the existence of legal proceedings to the defendants and facilitate the next stages of the case.
The development is nevertheless likely to draw diplomatic and legal attention, given the senior positions held by the individuals named in the lawsuit and the wider tensions surrounding allegations of transnational targeting.
