The Calcutta High Court has declined to treat recent social media posts by Trinamool Congress (TMC) leader Abhishek Banerjee criticising the judiciary as contempt of court, even while expressing strong displeasure over the remarks.
During a hearing on Friday, Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya said the comments were "painful" but did not appear to meet the threshold of wilful and deliberate contempt. The court also made it clear that the controversy surrounding the tweets would not be sufficient grounds to deny Banerjee continued interim protection in an ongoing criminal case.
The court accordingly extended the protection from coercive action granted to the TMC leader until January 29, 2027.
The issue came up after Additional Advocate General Rajdeep Mazumder informed the court that Banerjee had allegedly posted derogatory remarks targeting the High Court and the judiciary.
"He is repeatedly attacking the High Court and the Judiciary," Mazumder argued.
The bench, however, questioned whether social media criticism could automatically be treated as contemptuous conduct. It also asked whether the alleged posts represented a significant change in circumstances that would justify withdrawing the relief already granted to Banerjee.
"Is it wilful, deliberate, contumacious contempt? Can a tweet be the basis for contumacious contempt?" Justice Bhattacharyya asked.
While refusing to make the tweets a determining factor in the matter, the judge expressed concern about the influence of political leaders' statements on their supporters.
"Derogatory comments have been made about the Court, what message does it convey to his followers?" the court observed.
The bench added that although the remarks were objectionable, they did not constitute wilful, deliberate and contumacious contempt at this stage. The judge also questioned why Banerjee was making statements that could potentially harm his own legal position.
Responding to the allegations, Banerjee's lawyer said he was not aware of the tweets in question but would examine the circumstances surrounding them.
The court subsequently observed that the TMC leader had continued to cooperate with the investigation and that no material had been presented to establish otherwise. It therefore found no sufficient reason to deny him an extension of interim relief.
What Is the Criminal Case Against Banerjee?
The proceedings originate from a complaint over statements allegedly made by Banerjee during an election campaign rally on April 7. The complainant accused him of making provocative remarks against opposition workers and issuing a threat directed at Union Home Minister Amit Shah.
At the rally, Banerjee reportedly said: "I will see who comes to save them on May 4. I will see which godfather from Delhi comes to their rescue."
The High Court had previously criticised the alleged speech, describing the remarks as irresponsible and unnecessary. However, on May 21, it granted Banerjee protection against coercive action, on the condition that he cooperate with the investigation.
